Skip to content

Sherry Eggnog

The Sherry Eggnog is a light creamy cocktail, creamy on the palate. Shaken and served in a highball glass.

Flavor profile

Sweet
29 out of 100
Herbal
27 out of 100
Creamy
93 out of 100
Smoky
27 out of 100
Boozy
15 out of 100

How to make a Sherry Eggnog

To make a Sherry Eggnog, shake with ice and strain into a highball glass: 2 oz sherry, ¼ oz simple syrup, 1 whole egg, milk and 1 nutmeg.

You'll need

1 drink

Pairs well with: Simple syrup · All syrups

Instructions

  1. 1

    Add sherry, simple syrup, egg, milk and nutmeg to a cocktail shaker.

  2. 2

    Shake hard without ice for about 10 seconds to whip the egg.

  3. 3

    Add ice to the shaker.

  4. 4

    Shake again for 10-15 seconds, until the shaker feels very cold.

  5. 5

    Strain into a highball glass filled with fresh ice cubes.

Why shake? Milk blends in smoothly only with a hard shake; the egg needs a dry shake first to turn silky.

No simple syrup? Muddle 1 tsp sugar with a splash of water in the shaker until it dissolves, then carry on.

Sherry Eggnog questions

What does a Sherry Eggnog taste like?

Mostly creamy. It's a light drink at about 4% ABV once mixed.

How strong is a Sherry Eggnog?

About 4% ABV after mixing with ice, closer to a beer or glass of wine.

What's the difference between a Sherry Eggnog and a Sherry Flip?

Both use sherry, simple syrup, egg, milk and nutmeg. Both are shaken, but the Sherry Eggnog goes in a highball glass and the Sherry Flip in a coupe.

Should a Sherry Eggnog be shaken or stirred?

Shaken: simple syrup, egg white and milk need a hard shake to mix and chill properly. Dry-shake without ice first for a thicker foam.

What glass do you serve a Sherry Eggnog in?

A highball glass.